Friday, October 23, 2026
Book Review: Midnight Rising
Author: Tony Horwitz
Author's web page: http://tonyhorwitz.com/
Publisher: Henry Holt & Company
Date: 2011
Length: 290 pages of text, 55 pages of endnotes, 3 pages of image credits, 15-page index
Illustrations: maps, old photos and drawings
ISBN: 080509153X
Quote: "Viewed through the lens of 9/11, Harpers Ferry seems an al-Qaeda prequel: a long-bearded fundamentalist, consumed by hatred of the U.S. government, launches nineteen men in a suicidal strike on a symbol of American power. A shocked nation plunges into war."
As all Washingtonians know, Harpers Ferry is a picturesque, slightly touristy but mostly unspoiled, mountain town whose distinguishing features include a quaint old railroad that still runs passenger trains to and from D.C. While waiting for the train back to the city, you may read, talk, or knit, but you can't not notice the dramatic mountain and river view. To some people, including Horwitz, it seems "spooky." If a place has the right to be haunted, Harpers Ferry has...
Fair disclosure: my primary reason for reading this book was to find out how many of the nineteenth-century images of Harpers Ferry were drawn from the railroad station (several) and how much the view has changed (not terribly much). For me, the scenery is enough of an attraction, apart from the history of this town.
However, Harpers Ferry's big tourist attraction has been the history of the act of "Northern Aggression" that, as all Southerners know, really started the Civil War. Our ancestors wouldn't have fired on Fort Sumter if a megalomaniac, but not legally insane, Yankee hadn't attacked Harpers Ferry.
After 150 years, although the issues over which people were fighting even before 1860 seem surprisingly current, it's hard to take the old war rhetoric seriously. Horwitz has a good time at the expense of both sides. Many things people said and wrote even in the early nineteenth century can be clearly identified as either Green or Greedhead, and Horwitz shares some choice expressions of Greedhead thinking in the Old South. Not only did Southerners suffer from their own form of collective megalomania, or empire-building, as they envisioned a future in which their descendants would continue to exhaust the land and move on; while the best thinkers in the South understood that slavery was self-doomed, there were idiots who blithered in public about the need to evangelize and spread the benefits of slavery...
Meanwhile, in the North, several people who were indeed the best writers in their communities, if not the best thinkers, fell under the spell of John Brown's charismatic megalomania. Frederick Douglass kept some sensible reservations about Brown and his scheme. Amos Bronson Alcott, Henry David Thoreau, and Thomas Wentworth Higginson did not. (For those who've been wondering what possessed Emily Dickinson to call a writer so inferior as Higginson her "master," it seems likely that his freedom to act as well as write may have been his attraction.) Alcott called Brown "the manliest man" he ever saw, a "Christian brave and true"; Thoreau raged against his sentencing that Brown "could not have been tried by a jury of his peers, because his peers did not exist," and Louisa May Alcott effused, "Living, he made life beautiful,--Dying, made death divine."
Midnight Rising offers other glimpses of historical figures. Those acquainted with Wise County, Virginia, may particularly appreciate the mini-biography of then-Governor Henry Wise incorporated into this book. The story also has walk-on parts for James Buchanan, Herman Melville, Robert E. Lee, T.J. "Stonewall" Jackson, William Lloyd Garrison, and many more people whose names readers should know.
John Brown seems to have considered himself a Christian; it was just that Christ's warning that "those who take the sword will perish by the sword" seems not to have meant much to him...Horwitz tries to avoid passing moral judgment on Brown's act, to remain objective and simply trace its connections to other events in history. He hands over the job of concluding the story to Langston Hughes, whose poem ends, "Perhaps / You will recall / John Brown." You will, indeed.
Dozens of books had already been written about the Harpers Ferry raid, including a memoir by Osborne Anderson (a survivor) and a biography of Brown by W.E.B. Dubois. Did the world, or even the Harpers Ferry tourist business, really need another one? Well...adding Horwitz's talent to the body of existing books on the topic couldn't hurt anything. If you're going to read only one book about Harpers Ferry, I can't claim to have read enough of the others to say that Midnight Rising is "better" than they are, but it's a good read--written clearly and cleanly enough to make a challenging book for a bright middle school student, while still holding the interest of adults.
Wednesday, August 19, 2026
Book Review: The Four-Story Mistake
Author: Elizabeth Enright
Date: 1942
Publisher: Holt Rinehart & Winston
ISBN: my copy has none
Length: 177 pages
Illustrations: drawings by the author
Quote: "There were thirty acres of land that went with the house, and a sample of everything delightful, short of an active volcano and an ocean...brook, woods, stable, hollow tree, and summerhouse."
After the fictional Melendy family's New York brownstone caught fire, the old lady the children learned to appreciate in The Saturdays invited them to spend the summer at her beach house. Then she helped their father sell the brownstone and buy an old farmhouse in the Adirondacks where the children could explore the things that really interested their author. The Four-Story Mistake is the name of their new home (meant to be four storeys, it was built only three storeys high by mistake). Here they discover architecture, antiques, and history, especially the Victorian Era that most interested Elizabeth Enright.
They don't lose their own interests. Actually, they grow in them. Mona, whose fifteenth birthday apparently occurs during the time frame of the book, qualifies for a paid acting job in a 1940s live-production radio soap opera. (It could have happened, back then.) Thirteen-year-old Rush gets a tutoring job. Meanwhile, they discover the secret room where the Victorian papa tried to wall off the memory of his runaway daughter, ride to school on antique bicycles, and will be cruising around, by the end of the book, in a surrey with fringe on top.
Of course, this book is a piece of its own historical period too. It's not just that the Melendys are Christians, in the bland unobtrusive way mainstream publishers expected at the time. It's that when they raise money by putting on talent shows, or even find a genuine diamond in the brook, they rush into town to buy...war bonds!
Some children enjoy learning new words from context clues, in phrases like "their swelling necks and biceps," "a light shining vertically through the rain," or "junior prima donnas temperamenting around the house." These children may or may not have been formally identified as gifted, themselves, but they also enjoy reading about the gifted and talented Melendy family; they're the ones who kept these books in print for forty years.
Perhaps family members who can explain concepts like war bonds and gramophones to eight-year-olds are in shorter supply than they were in the 1970s. Perhaps, too, the three later volumes in this four-book series gave me more pleasure than the first ones because they have a strong regional flavor; they're about the Appalachian Mountains all right, and there's not a coal mine or a moonshiner in this book. (There's a moonshiner in Then There Were Five, though.) Still, this is a classic book by a Newbery Award author. Every child deserves the opportunity to discover Enright's books.
Tuesday, July 28, 2026
Book Review: Small Wonder
Author: Barbara Kingsolver
Author's web page: http://www.kingsolver.com/
Date: 2002
Publisher: Harper Collins
ISBN: 0-06-050406-2
Length: 264 pages plus foreword and acknowledgments
Illustrations: drawings by Paul Mirocha
Quote: "I began this book, without exactly knowing I was doing so, on September 12, 2001."
After the physical attacks by Al-Qaeda on September 11 came the long siege of emotional terrorism by People Who Are Part of the Problem (Without Knowing It), which began, in the newspapers, on September 12. It was a weird season for writers. Even comedy writers were asked to write about The Tragedies, not because they had anything to say that anyone else didn't know, but so that certain newspapers could print All September 11 All The Time.
The emotion I remember feeling in the last third of the year 2001 was irritation. So much that was being said and written about the situation in the United States, or even in Washington, showed such total ignorance about what the people I knew were actually thinking, feeling, doing.
Real memories: The autumn of 2001 was beautiful, with day after day of picture-perfect weather. Grass had grown over the graves where my father had been buried in January and my husband's brother in November. Cormorants moved into the Anacostia Waterfront Park. Some creep mailed anthrax culture to a few personal enemies at the same time that a nasty strep infection was going through the D.C. schools. Despite strep throat my husband and I went to Stitches Fair and Knit Out.
Some reverberations from The Tragedies did reach us. We turned down a trip to Ireland because the airlines had become so tiresome. We discussed a Caribbean cruise, then ended up actually going to a memorial service for a friend who died of cancer in California. First we laughed at W Bush's advice to patriotic Americans to spend money ("What did you do in the War on Terrorism, Daddy?" "I charged!"), and then we did some serious thinking and writing about the benefits of buying locally produced items, which did not include the China-made flags other people were buying.
Barbara Olson, whose books I'd cited in research writing, was on one of the planes that were hijacked. That was sad, but the losses of personal friends and relatives and the well-earned success of another friend's book (the book parties started in January) took up more of our emotional energy.
I mention this because it resonates with some of the essays in Small Wonder. Kingsolver was not a newspaper wage slave obliged to crank out a certain number of words about yesterday's headlines before breakfast. She had lots of things to say that other people were not saying. She was writing about pollution and conservation, wildlife and child life, fiction, nonfiction, poetry, being a successful novelist, foreign aid, national parks, pesticides, the "locavore" eating plan, going to Japan, the Columbine tragedy. She mentions in Small Wonder that she felt only about as sad, when John Kennedy (junior) died, as she imagined Caroline Kennedy would have felt if a member of the Kingsolver family had died. And some people were outraged. How dare people be more emotionally involved with their own lives than with the public events blaring out of the TV.
The four "September 11" essays in Small Wonder are, to my mind, dreadful...but then all of them were. They were products of a very bad idea: the idea of cheapening the real grief and anguish some people were feeling by ramming phony anguish down the nation's throats until mass nausea set in.
The other essays in Small Wonder are Green and/or literary. They contain some opinions I don't support, but they also contain so many useful facts and quotes that I bought this book for reference purposes anyway. The natural history pieces are beautiful.
There is one inexcusable mistake in this book. Kingsolver is a native of Kentucky. After living in the West for several years, she moved to Virginia. She doesn't want to name the town in Small Wonder. I won't name it either, although I know which town it is...but it's not Appalachia. In Kentucky "Appalachia" may mean the mountainous half of the state, but in Virginia it is the name of one particular town. Kingsolver has been here long enough to know.
There is also some very good writing, research, and thinking in this book. There is, for example, the discussion of genetic modification on pages 93-108. I've read longer and shorter, older and newer, essays on this topic. From time to time I've even contemplated writing one. I remain unconvinced that a better essay on genetic modification can be written. If you've not made a study of this topic, Small Wonder is an excellent place to begin.
I completely agree with Kingsolver on genetic modification. I completely disagree with her on the place of cats in our ecology. So I can tell you that it's possible to enjoy her writing even if you're reading it to use her facts for the purpose of further research intended to refute her interpretation of the facts. Small Wonder and this writer's other books are recommended to anyone who is not frightened by numbers and who appreciates a well-rounded, realistic, humanitarian approach to science.
Tuesday, September 30, 2025
Book Review: Grief Hollow
Title: Sour Roots
Author: Shawn Burgess
Date: 2022
Quote: "With each step they took, the forest grew darker."
In an unspecified deep, dark, creepy part of the Appalachian Mountains, worse things than mold and rot haunt a place soon to be known as Grief Hollow.
One of them is a nameless "fallen woman" who, over years of living alone with grief, shame, and revenge, has transformed into a nightmare creature in the general category of what mountain people used to call Boogers. (The word is probably of Celtic origin, but during some war or other it was deliberately confused with "Bulgarian" and words for what were supposed to be that country's bad habits.) Traditional Boogers were emissaries of the Devil who came to lead sinners to their judgment. They didn't need to look worse than ugly, sooty humans. The only description of them usually given is that they were black (from spending time in the Eternal Fire) and ugly. They led or carried people away to a gruesome fate.
This one, however, seems a bit more like the "Dogmen" of more recent urban legends from further west. The look of a "Dogman" has been explained as based on a view of a bear with a disease that can cause bears' fur to fall out Bears occasionally stand and walk on their hind feet. A bald bear on its hind feet looks a bit like a naked human with a dog's head, only bigger than either human or dog. It might be willing and able to eat a human alive. It would have leathery skin, black if it were the Appalachian Mountains' black bear, and lots of teeth and claws. If it made a sound, the sound would probably be a growl or snarl. That's how Westerners describe Dogmen. It's also how Shawn Burgess describes the resident of Grief Hollow in the 1920s.
In addition to the "honey" whose humanity died in Grief Hollow long ago, whose sole purpose for existing is to get revenge on him, the man who abandoned her has a brain-damaged son, a ladylike but minimally competent wife who's doomed to spend her life keeping her son out of sight, and two little daughters whose idea of rebellion is playing in the forest. Where, in the first chapter, first the children hear a malevolent whisper that they've "come home," then they find themselves running--feeling that they're being chased--toward a crumbling house, and then something with black leathery skin and a lot of teeth and claws eats them.
Meanwhile a turned-out sharecropper (in the Deep South they were usually Black, but in the mountains they were more often White) wanders past Grief Hollow. There a grieving father insists that he be hanged for the murder of the little girls of whom only bloodstained scraps have been found. After all, he's clearly not intelligent and he doesn't know the names of the places he's wandered through. The father wants to vent his feelings on somebody. It's not as if the sharecropper will be missed.
Drawing energy from the children, the monster from Grief Hollow shows herself to their mother and brother. Just describing what she's seen gets the mother declared insane. The brother, who's never been given credit for intelligence, blathers about "the lady from the mist" being his friend...
The grief will grow from these sour roots for another hundred years, and three volumes, if you want to read them. If you like horror fiction, you probably will. The story is told vividly but tastefully, by the special standards applied to horror fiction, and points to Burgess for leaving the usual moonshiners and outhouses out of this story.
Friday, August 1, 2025
Bad Poetry: Scab
Friday, July 25, 2025
Ode to John McCutcheon on the Occasion of His 45th Record Album
Thursday, July 17, 2025
Vanishing Words
Wednesday, April 24, 2024
History Will Be the Judge of Songs That Confuse Children
Sunday, December 10, 2023
Local Christian Book Review: A Second Chance for Sugarplums
Friday, September 29, 2023
Bad Poetry: Things That Feel Like Home
Sunday, April 2, 2023
Morgan Griffith on US HR 1, the Lower Energy Costs Act
The E-Newsletter is long; editorial response is below. From U.S. Representative Morgan Griffith, R-VA-9:
"
The Lower Energy Costs Act
House Republicans recently passed H.R. 1, the Lower Energy Costs Act. By numbering this legislation as H.R. 1, Republicans recognize that unleashing American energy is one of Congress’ top priorities and critical to the wellbeing of the American people and our economy.
In 2020, under President Trump, the United States achieved energy independence. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, the U.S. produced more petroleum than it consumed, the first year since at least 1949. Unfortunately, this energy comeback was short-lived.
On his very first day in office, President Biden began enacting policies to counter the energy achievements made in the last Administration, ones that severely hampered domestic oil and gas production. As a result, the American people have experienced exorbitant energy prices.
The Biden Administration made permitting new fossil fuel and nuclear energy projects very difficult. The New York Times recently reported that even thousands of renewable energy projects are delayed due to the current regulatory landscape.
In parts of Virginia gas prices reached record highs, close to $5 a gallon in June 2022. The price of residential heating oil hit an all-time high in November, costing Virginians $5.52 per gallon.
This has been especially burdensome for low-income households; some families in the 9th District have had to choose between paying their energy bills to keep their homes heated during the winter and other necessities.
We can do better.
H.R. 1 incorporates 25 individual pieces of legislation from across three different standing House committees to address the energy issues we have experienced over the past few years.
As a member of the Energy and Commerce Committee and the Energy Subcommittee, I have been proud to be one of the people working to make H.R. 1 a good bill.
H.R. 1 aims to increase domestic energy production and alleviate some of the cost increases at the pump, by reversing Biden’s anti-energy policies.
It includes legislation to disapprove of Biden’s canceling of the Keystone XL pipeline, which cost the United States 11,000 American jobs and could have had a positive economic impact of between $3.4-9.6 billion. The additional oil would have been cheaper to transport to American refineries by pipeline, rather than moving the oil by truck or train. This would have kept gasoline prices from rising as much.
The legislation also requires the Department of the Interior to resume lease sales on federal lands and waters and repeals many restrictions on the import and export of natural gas, including LNG.
About half of the homes in the United States use natural gas for space heating and water heating. Included in H.R.1 is legislation to repeal President Biden’s natural gas production tax. This tax has played a hand in increasing household energy bills across the country.
H.R. 1 reforms the country’s permitting process through changes to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) permitting process. These changes will streamline federal environmental reviews for all sectors of our economy by ensuring that NEPA review challenges are substantive and by setting deadlines for completion of the NEPA reviews.
This energy package also repeals Section 134 of the Clean Air Act, relating to the greenhouse gas reduction fund. This $27 billion ‘green bank’ was implemented as part of the so-called Inflation Reduction Act to advance the bad policies of the Green New Deal.
The legislation also addresses our need for domestic production of critical minerals. In the left’s rush to green energy, America has become too reliant on volatile Chinese supply chains, and in some cases, the use of slave labor. The Department of Energy reported that, among other things, China controls 80% of the world’s rare earths production and refining which is needed to manufacture wind turbines and 60% of lithium refining needed for electric vehicles and battery storage.
I believe in an all-of-the-above energy approach, including renewables, but it shouldn’t be at the expense of our national security. This legislation boosts the mining and processing of hardrock minerals, including critical minerals needed to ramp-up production of renewable energy components, maximizing our domestic energy production. It also requires the Department of Energy to identify resources that are particularly vulnerable to supply disruptions.
Unfortunately, before the House passed H.R. 1, President Biden threatened to veto the legislation, to the detriment of all Americans.
Hopefully the Senate will work with us to get a bill that helps Americans by lowering energy costs.
If you have questions, concerns, or comments, feel free to contact my office. You can call my Abingdon office at 276-525-1405 or my Christiansburg office at 540-381-5671. To reach my office via email, please visit my website at www.morgangriffith.house.gov. On my website is the latest material from my office, including information on votes recently taken on the floor of the House of Representatives
"
Editorial response:
We can do better than fossil fuels and nuclear energy, too, in the Ninth District.
We have lots of sunshine. Well, we get plenty of rain too--but we do get enough sunshine to generate electricity from solar collectors.
We have lots of paved parking lots that people would like to have sheltered. With solar collectors? Why not?
We have lots of old farmhouses with lots of outbuildings, all of which have roofs, all of which roofs could be supporting solar collectors. Some of these buildings are no longer in use for their original purposes--especially the tobacco barns!--and could be used as battery sheds.
We have too many store and office buildings that have cheap, flat roofs that hold water and sag, and often leak, and badly need to be capped with roofs that slope and drain off water. Big roofs. That would hold lots and lots of solar collectors.
Almost every needy family, almost every retired couple, almost every business in the Ninth District, has an untapped source of energy...enough to meet our own requirements, and to sell to people in the cities who don't have roofs or pavements of their own. We should be Virginia's leading producer and exporter of CLEAN energy.
APCo should be sending us monthly checks, and sending Pepco and Dominion bills!
Regulations that seem to make this difficult are the work of protectionist corporate interests. We need a sensible conservative Congress to cut through those regulations like a hot knife through a stick of butter.
You, Mr. Griffith, know your way around by now and should be in an ideal position to slash through the red tape and put the Point of Virginia at the front of twenty-first-century technology. And the retirees, the business owners, and the working parents of the Ninth District will love you for it.


