Wednesday, September 10, 2025

Book Review: Busman's Honeymoon

Title: Busman’s Honeymoon

Author: Dorothy Sayers

Date: 1937

Publisher: Harper & Row

ISBN: 0-06-080823-3

Length: 370 pages

Quote: “Peter Wimsey is married—yes, actually married—to that extraordinary young woman...Peter must be forty-five if he’s a day.”

A “busman’s holiday” was a leisure trip in the bus. In this volume of their adventures Lord and Lady Peter Wimsey find themselves solving a murder mystery on their honeymoon.

Sayers had already explained the rule under which, upon marriage to Lord Peter, Harriet Vane acquired the title “Lady Peter” rather than, more logically, Lady Harriet. Possibly the off-putting sound of this title has something to do with the fact that she remains plain Harriet to herself and her friends.

Anyway, she’d helped Lord Peter solve a few other cases since he proved her innocent of the murder of her ex-boyfriend, and now they’re full partners in crime—solving them, that is. Those who’ve found Partners-for-Life will appreciate this fictional rendition of something rare and wonderful. This couple’s passion for each other is matched only by their passion for solving murder mysteries. If it makes them the most eccentric aristocrats in England, it may make them the happiest. The joy they feel at this time in their lives would probably have sustained them if their first detective adventure as a married couple had involved gruesome murders, but, perhaps out of compassion for readers, Sayers gives them a case distinguished by its cleanness.

Sayers, a Christian, never gave Lord Peter Wimsey the emotional comfort of religion. (He’s had a Christian education, has clergymen as friends, and goes around quoting Christian literature, but he lost any faith in a “personal” God in the trenches in the 1914 war.) In her mind the only really religious, as distinct from cultural, Christian element in her detective stories was that she refused to “cheapen life” by inventing unlovable stick figures who exist only to be murdered. In her novels Lord Peter’s whimsical mind, always dredging up quotes and fun facts, always guarantees a Comedy element; his empathy for the victims always guarantees a Tragedy element; and his relationship with unaccountably coy Harriet—who didn’t want to be accused of marrying him for his money, but in this volume we learn that her ex-boyfriend had also conditioned her not to like sex—added a Romance. 

We have here, therefore, a Tragedy, a Comedy, a Romance, and a Mystery, all in one volume, and the last thing Sayers would have wanted was for anyone to mistake this four-genre triumph for a Christian Novel as well. She thought of her detective stories as potboilers that subsidized the relatively smaller stack of religious writing she found time to do. Nevertheless she worked them out with all the joy of duty and pleasure that she described in The Mind of the Maker, and that she gives to Peter and Harriet—and it shows. If you like novels at all, you just about have to like Busman’s Honeymoon.

No comments:

Post a Comment