Showing posts with label 1930s. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1930s. Show all posts

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Book Review: Dachau Review (Volumes 1 and 2)

Apologies to those who think a dictatorship, pushed to cut population along the lines of hate it had been using for other purposes, is too real for Halloween. This Halloween, I think it's real enough that it should distract us from the cute little ghost and witch costumes. Not only do we have a party that overtly wants Socialism; that party has formed an alliance with a group who hate Jews. If ghosts can haunt, a lot of grandfathers are coming out after their grandchildren this Halloween.

Title: Dachau Review

Editor: Wolfgang Benz

Publisher: Comite Internal de Dachau, Brussels

Date: 1988

Length: 240 pages (v. 1), 206 pages (v. 2)

ISBN: 0854962697

Quote: "The Dachau Review is the first volume of a new periodical which contains in unabridged form in English the most important contributions of the previous three issues of the Dachauer Hefte."

These two cheaply produced, poorly bound paperbacks aren't fun to read. They weren't meant to be. They're a serious, scholarly collection of survivors' accounts and historians' studies of the German prison camps during the 1930s and early 1940s. Their purpose is to document the atrocities that really happened, and dispel the myths.

Although there's no reasonable doubt that the prison camps were the scenes of atrocities, one thing these reports confirm is the huge amount of concealment and deception that went on, the impossibility of knowing for sure whether some stories were true or false. Prisoners lied, for obvious reasons. Prison managers also lied, for reasons that may be less obvious. Bribery often worked, and the value of a bribe was completely unpredictable: a gold tooth might buy a prisoner a cup of dirty water, or a plausible English passport. Threats were used as discipline. Rumors abounded.

So, were prisoners' bodies used to manufacture household goods? After reviewing the evidence Benz, Barbara Distel, and others can't really say that that never happened; all they can say is that no such goods were found.

Were masses of prisoners gassed in shower rooms? In some other places--first in nursing homes for elderly and disabled "Aryans"--that happened. "In Dachau no gas chambers were used," our researchers report. In Dachau prisoners could be shot for any breach of discipline, for becoming unable to work, or just to intimidate other prisoners, but rumors about gas chambers seem to have been based solely on the existence of crematoria, which no living prisoner had actually entered. Poison gas cost money; both gas and money were in short supply. Guards and overseers could be vicious--there was no penalty for beating a prisoner to death. Still, starvation and infectious diseases killed far more prisoners than were either euthanized due to illness, executed according to what passed for due process of law, or murdered outright.

Were the majority of those imprisoned, or of those killed in the camps, Jewish? Not at Dachau.

Were individual guards kind enough to help individual prisoners escape? Sometimes, but not often or predictably. One informant describes having to thank for saving his brother's life the same guard he blamed for killing his mother.

In the end, how many people--Jewish or otherwise--did the Nazis kill? No true answer will ever be known. The number is certainly in the millions, but too much lying and destruction of evidence went on for any estimates to be accepted as facts. These books contain some eyewitness accounts of faked deaths that may or may not have allowed prisoners to escape.

Certainly faked deaths did allow several of the presumed dead to survive. In a family I know two teenaged boys, first cousins who had been friends, disappeared at about the same time. During the year each young man mourned the other's death, they were living within a mile of each other in London. Both enjoyed long and successful lives, and were able to recognize each other and share memories when one of those fifty-years-later TV programs featured one of the cousins.

Holocaust deniers have even cited the case of an entire town whose Jewish population, apparently decimated during the Holocaust, surged back almost to prewar levels between 1945 and 1946. And not many houses or businesses had been sold, either during or after the war, either. Apparently there was just a benign conspiracy to accept, for the duration of the war, that a few thousand individuals had never been Jewish--whom did people think they were talking about?--until it was safe for these people to identify themselves as Jewish again.

Unfortunately it wasn't always so easy, and while the species of contrarians known as Holocaust deniers were able to disprove some claims without much difficulty, the Nazi Holocaust was just too big to fake.

Meanwhile, people who view the Holocaust from a different historical perspective have exaggerated the sadism of the Third Reich and overlooked the profit motive. Dachau was built not to torture or kill men, but to profit from their labor as the (alleged) criminals "paid their debt to society." As long as it was profitable to keep prisoners healthy, most were well enough fed and sheltered, even medicated where possible, to keep them alive (as slaves) for years. That's why there were so many survivors. 

But why, now that most of the survivors have written out their memories and died of old age, do we need to go on reading about it? Certainly not for pleasure; and I for one don't think there's any comfort to be gained from comparing our own immediate misery with someone else's theoretically greater misery. If you're feeling sad because you didn't win the competition or the person you've had a crush on has asked someone else for a date, reading about how the victorious U.S. troops found one group of seventeen almost-survivors who were too sick and starved to digest food when they were fed may help you put your angst into perspective, but it's unlikely to make you feel good. (If it does, I don't want to know you.)

I don't get any particular jollies from thinking about "the triumph of the human spirit" in the survivors, either. My brother, adoptive sister, and I inherited the non-depressive gene along with the brown eyes and crooked teeth genes. My natural sister got the alternative genes. That humans can agree that some genetic traits are more pleasant to be around than others doesn't say anything particularly uplifting about the human spirit, to me.

Some survivors learned moral lessons in the prison camps, although that's not what you'll find in the Dachau Review. In one of Bob Schuller's books, reviewed here last week, a survivor shared the edifying story of how his camp usually offered two kinds of food to prisoners: bread, and soup. The bread was cold, coarse, and unflavored, and tasted vile, but did contain some fibre and nutrients from whole grains. The soup absorbed some flavor, but was usually just a cup of hot water with very little nutrient value. Some prisoners would trade their bread for other prisoners' soup rations...and at the end of the war, all the survivors turned out to be bread eaters; the soup sippers starved. Preachers have already publicized that kind of stories. The Dachau Review didn't need them, or use them.

So, what made this well-fed, non-Jewish American pay hard-earned cash for these books? Supporting the library that allows me to maintain this web site was one reason, but why choose the Dachau Review over the "westerns" and romances that had also been donated to the library's benefit sale? Obviously, I thought these books deserved resale; I do think this piece of history has some relevance to our time.

It's best stated, though oddly reversed, by Ralph Giordano in volume two: "I warn you young people of today: don't let anyone tell you that this undemocratically and un-humanly motivated anti-communism ever was, is or will be anything other than the belligerent brother of its own professed diametrical opponent."

Germany, a smaller country already impoverished by losing another idiot dictator's useless war, collapsed faster under National Socialism than Russia did under Soviet Socialism. In both countries, and in most other countries that have experimented with socialism, the socialist government collapsed and the result was chaos, wars, plagues, and mass deaths. A few countries that flirted with socialism, like Britain and China, have survived by learning from examples and giving up unsustainable socialist schemes. Either of those things could happen here.

German Jews, Lutherans, and "Communist" atheists had not exactly liked each other, but had coexisted peacefully, in times of prosperity. Religion became a cause of hate and war when the people felt poverty-stricken and desperate. Hitler whipped up hate of both minorities in order to unite the majority for his own self-aggrandizing purposes, while telling people he trusted how much he preferred the war and death cults of Pagan Germany to the Protestant churches he had to exploit. (What has survived of Germanic Pagan mythology was complex; there were "gods" and cults of love and peace, as well as war and death; Hitler had no use for the nice ones.) These United States have prospered as a nominally Christian, in practice predominantly Humanist, nation where all religions are tolerated...until what are still a minority of Americans have started to feel poverty-stricken, and although I doubt that most of these people know anything about poverty, immediately mistrust of all religions but one's own (including the pseudo-religion of atheism) sets in. Religious hate could happen here. Even the explosion of religious hate into mass violent insanity could happen here.

Hitler really owed his success, though, less to hate than to his Biggest Lie of All--the seductive lie that Germans could recover prosperity, rather than sinking into real plague-and-famine poverty, by giving their leaders total power over every aspect of life. The United Nations, once the trusted mediator between Europeans like Stalin and Hitler, has succumbed to this fantasy with its "Agenda 21" bid for total control over every aspect of life in every member nation. To the extent that the ostensibly civilized nations of the world cooperate with Agenda 21 or any of its successor schemes, the totalitarian government and the poverty it produces could very easily happen here...in the U.S., in the U.K., in any part of Europe or of any other continent, or, if the lunatics in the U.N. get their way, in all of them.

Probably everyone has, and should have, our own way of saying "Never Again." For me, as an American Christian, "Never Again" tends to blur into an older slogan: "Love all (never buy into collective hate as any kind of solution to anything), trust few (never entrust anyone with more power than is necessary to prevent violent crime), and always paddle your own canoe (make your own decisions based on what you observe where you are, which really is something about which you would know more than anyone else could)."

The Dachau Review is a good clear explanation of the alternative.

Wednesday, July 15, 2026

Book Review: All Creatures Great and Small

Title: All Creatures Great and Small

Author: James Herriot

Date: 1972

Publisher: Bantam / St Martin’s

ISBN: 0-553-10759-3

Length: 499 pages

Quote: “My mind went back to that picture in the obstetrics book...There was no dirt or blood or sweat anywhere.”

The author known as James Herriot earned his living as a veterinarian for years, but really made his fortune when he started writing about his animal patients and the humans who helped and hurt them. Although most of his readers no longer lived with cows and sheep, each book contained some instructive, and some merely poignant or funny, stories about dogs, cats, and horses too. Gruesome details about animals’ diseases are scattered sparsely amidst charming pictures of country landscapes and amusing pieces of human folly. Through the 1970s and 1980s these books were bestsellers.

Of course, some of the people mentioned in these stories were still living, so names and identifying details had to be fictionalized. This volume of a five-book series focusses on the quirks of Herriot’s first employer and co-worker, to whom he gives the names of Siegfried and Tristan Farnon and a story about parents who loved opera. Dr. Farnon and Dr. Herriot are young bachelors; Tristan is a student; the lady known to readers as Helen Alderson Herriot is a pretty, popular girl who can hardly fail to see the farcical side of the three guys’ mostly ridiculous dating lives, but eventually marries James Herriot...and gets a ridiculous honeymoon adventure, at least in the book, as her immediate reward. A theme that runs through the book is the image of an elderly man reflecting on how silly youth is. This image may have served as a drop of oil on the waters in 1972, when grandparents were often called upon to reduce the tensions between students and their parents. Helen is cast as the sensible straightman while Siegfried, Tristan, and James make fools of themselves as regularly as their contemporaries in the novels of P.G. Wodehouse.

All the names in these books, including the author's, are fiction; the author's real name was Wight. The events in the stories happened, but not necessarily in the same sequence, or involving the same people, as the books suggest. Herriot originally planned four long volumes, All Things Bright and Beautiful, All Creatures Great and Small, All Things Wise and Wonderful, and The Lord God Made Them All; later, by popular demand, he added a sequel entitled Every Living Thing. All are worth reading for pleasure, although the stories are fact-based fiction and the veterinary insights are a hundred years out of date.

Still, some information is evergreen. Instructive stories in All Creatures Great and Small feature a spoiled, overfed dog who nearly died from overeating but recovered his health when put on a reducing diet and treated like a dog, a sad sequence of cows who died because their humans never called the vet until it was too late, and a cow whose inflammation was actually cured by a devoted human who sat up bathing and massaging the cow all night. There are also warnings about the less obvious symptoms of tuberculosis in cattle and the postpartum “madness” in which mother animals can become dangerous. The birth process is draining even in animals, like cats, who give birth easily; brain chemicals can be unbalanced; animal mothers may attack their humans or, less often, their babies.

Although the stories fit together into a sequence with an overarching "story arc," each chapter can be considered an independent short story. If your leisure reading time is limited, no worries—all the books in this series are ideal for those who choose to read just one short chapter a day. Since the only aspect of these books that is less than tasteful is the inherent disgustingness of veterinary medicine, the books also provide what might be called good clean wholesome gross-outs for middle school readers.

This book is warmly recommended to anyone who has not already read it, with the warning that most people over age thirty probably have. 

Tuesday, July 14, 2026

Book Review: Hour of Gold Hour of Lead

Title: Hour of Gold Hour of Lead

Author: Anne Morrow Lindbergh

Date: 1973

Publisher: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich

ISBN: none

Length: 323 pages with index

Illustrations: four black-and-white photo inserts

Quote: “I was warned by my husband-to-be...‘nver write anything you wuld mind seeing on the front page of a news­paper.’..I stopped writing in my diary completely for three years.”

The “hour of gold” in this book is what Mrs. Lindbergh wrote about her life during those three years. As a result, the first section of her memoir, the happy bit, is sketchy, patchy, and not much fun to read; it consists of letters that were preserved by friends and relatives, but the letters were kept as short and cryptic as possible. She was a minor celebrity in her own right, married to a major one. Although it was well known that both of the glamorous couple liked their privacy, they were hounded by reporters, fans, and weirdos wherever they went. The photo sections show that they were too good-looking, in too conspicuous a way, to get far incognito.

The second section comes from the “hour of lead,” in which Mrs. Lindbergh resumed keeping a diary to vent the anguish she felt when her first child, Charles Junior, was kidnapped. A few older people still remember how the newspapers publicized the Lindberghs’ effort to raise ransom money, only to discover that Junior had been dead all along.

In the third section, after the long crisis period, Mrs. Lindbergh seems to have felt that she reached a degree of healing. Since we’re still reading letters and diaries that were written at the time, this resolution is not as obvious as a more psychotherapy-oriented book might have tried to make it. What may be most important, for any reader who might have lost a family member, is what Mrs. Lindbergh seems never to have needed to say in so many words: the Lindberghs didn’t blame each other for the tragedy. They grieved. Sometimes they isolated themselves, apparently by mutual consent, and sometimes they tried to be nice to each other. They believed that marriage was for life. In some ways they seem to have grown closer together; among other things Charles Lindbergh seems to have resigned himself, although this isn’t spelled out in so many words either, to the fact that he’d married a writer, who was going to write, and write about him, and if he wanted any privacy he’d better keep her manuscripts well guarded rather than trying to discourage her writing.

They were Christians, in a modest and unobtrusive way, but this third section is not the religious story some readers might have hoped for. There is a rather derisive reference to the kind of people who were saying that of course God had been holding up the planes, earlier in the book. Mrs. Lindbergh refers vaguely to a “Christian belief in immortality, in rebirth,” which aren’t the biblical words and which now suggest Pagan beliefs more than Christian ones, but she was not a theologian—or even a Bible maven—and probably we do know what she meant; in 1932 relatively few Neo-Pagans were using “rebirth” to mean “reincarnation,” and likewise relatively few fundamentalists were asking churchgoers whether they had been Born Again. What is specifically described in this “healing” section are temporal kinds of love. Charles Lindbergh was “marvelous.” Having the rest of the family still alive, in another day’s entry Mrs. Lindbergh reports someone tactlessly saying to her, “But you are happy,” then lists her living relatives, friends, and in-laws and concludes, “Yes, I am happy.” By the end of the book there’s another baby. 

This book is recommended to anyone interested in studying Mrs. Lindbergh as a writer, and to any bereaved persons who can tolerate the possibility that a simple day-by-day narration of someone else’s grief might sound even more appalling than whatever they’ve been going through.

Readers with depressive tendencies may need to be warned that, although Mrs. Lindbergh later remembered the last months of 1932 as the end of her time in the depths of grief, even on page 317 she’s still feeling “bitterly and passionately that I had lived too much in the past years.” The book ends on a hopeful note, with a friend who had seemed near death recovering enough to be married, but it stops short of the really happy times that lay ahead as the Lindberghs continued flying, writing about flying and about other things, and raising their other children.

If you’re depressive and doing research on the writer or her family, you need only slog through this book and on to the next volume—but it’s a long slog and I don’t currently have a copy of the next volume to offer. However, your library might still have one. 

Sunday, May 17, 2026

Book Review: Destiny Delayed

Title: Destiny Delayed

Author: Teresa E. Nelson

Quote: "Donald Swenquist didn't want to be a peace officer when he was a child."

Of all the books people have published on Kindle when they must have meant to revise the manuscript again, this is the most obvious I've seen so far. Donald is a child of the Depression with plenty to be depressed about. His father is an alcoholic; his mother may be that, or may also be a schizophrenic, or maybe both. Early in life he's sent to stay with another couple in the country. Local police come out to talk to the new boys (Donald has younger brothers) about stolen bicycles, and Donald convinces them that another boy is stealing bicycles, then catches the other boy and proves his charges. Knowing that he'll need a good job when he grows up, Donald's foster father encourages him to do errands and odd jobs for the police. It goes well; he helps rescue a straying child, and they send him to "police school." Donald has a girlfriend from high school who goes away to nursing school and becomes involved in crime, in a very innocent and pitiful sort of way, but that problem seems to be resolved...when Donald's mother comes looking for him.

So, is Donald adult enough to be kind to his mother while continuing to work for an organization she hates, or child enough to be sucked back into her dysfunctional life? We are not told. The e-book ends with the mother being glad she's found him. Is his "destiny" to be the nice middle-class life he's looking forward to as a "peace officer," or misery in the slums with his parents? We are not told.

This is not a book. It's part of a book manuscript. It should not have been published and should now be withdrawn from publication, finished, and published when it becomes a real, printable book.

It should be worth reading, when it's done. Nelson writes simply but clearly, and handles the specifically Christian scenes well. 

Wednesday, December 17, 2025

Book Review: You and I and Yesterday

This review appeared here many years ago, when I had a physical copy of the book for sale. It sold. These short essays go all through the year; some of them fit into the Christmas theme. 

Title: You and I and Yesterday

Author: Marjorie Holmes

Publisher: William Morrow & Company

Date: 1973

Length: 191 pages

Amazon ASIN tracking number: B002K4YKZK

Illustrations: line drawings, presumably by the author

Quote: "[T]he Good Old Days. Were they all that good? No, frankly not...The pain and humiliation of that desperate time left scars. But the Depression stiffened our backs and toughened our moral muscles. Nobody brainwashed us into thinking that the government owed us a living."

Marjorie Holmes was a gracious, gentle, witty Washington hostess. When she died in 2004, she was 91 years old. Women of her age and type did not beat people over the head with their religious and political views. Holmes was both Christian and conservative--and that's "conservative" in terms of my grandparents' generation--but, although this book describes the background of a Christian conservative growing up in the early twentieth century, it's almost pure reminiscence. Vivid sensory images. Adults' chores, children's games, the food people ate, the cars they drove, the movies they watched. You and I and Yesterday is a work of cultural history that was targeted toward a Christian conservative market...but if you're not Christian or conservative, you can still enjoy reading it.

Holmes' classes and conversation were liberal, in that sense, too. It used to be expected of Washingtonians.

What readers learn about in this book are kites, Maypoles, roller skates, gardening, parades, street games, canning vegetables, making fudge, silent movies, street peddlers, playgrounds, hanging out laundry on the line, haymaking, aprons, mail-order catalogues, singing as evening entertainment, antique cars, circuses, Chautauquas, Christmas trees, and a few brief glances at the personalities of Holmes' parents.

You and I and Yesterday can be shared with children. In fact it begs to be shared with children. The vocabulary should be an enjoyable challenge to middle school readers, and the reminiscences of things children did in the 1920s and 1930s should inspire many hours of frugal fun.

Wednesday, October 8, 2025

Book Review: You Can't Go Home Again

No worries, Gentle Readers. Your e-books are still in the computer, assuming they arrived in a format the computer can read. (Many Kindle e-books didn't, or if they did the computer can't read them any more.) I have just been too busy in the real world to make the time to read them. I will be working on this and will try to post more reviews of books that might suggest Halloween costumes, to go with Karen McSpade's newest (look for it on the 28th of October). More wet days like this one--as long as the cables hold up!--will bring more new book reviews. For today, here's the announcement of a classic:

Title: You Can’t Go Home Again

Author: Thomas Wolfe

Date: 1938, 1992

Publisher: Harper Collins

ISBN: 0-06-080986-8

Length: 576 pages

Quote: “I mean do you think you can really go home again?”

He can (and does) and he can’t; that’s the point of this novel.

Could George Webber’s sense of having lost and found “home” have been explained in fewer than 576 pages? Yes, but then readers would lose all the sketches of the people he meets in his travels. Wolfe’s talent was such that, even though most of these people appear in just one short vignette apiece, the book as a whole would be poorer without their stories. They’re good sketches; you just might recognize your grandfather in one of them.

Having been written in the 1930s, Wolfe’s stories of what Americans call the Great Depression are clear-eyed, with no “good old days” sentimentality. Life was hard for many people. Too many things had changed too quickly to suit many people. Neither Wolfe nor his character would be likely to have lapsed into “the world’s falling to pieces because all you younger people are fools” maunderings if they’d been alive in 1992. (Actually, as I recall, most people of their age hadn’t really got there even in the 1960s, when many of my generation were, however, too busy yelling about hair lengths and curfews to notice.) One gets the impression that if Wolfe were still around, he’d recognize his characters in the styles their kind of people are wearing today.

This is not a very plotty novel. Many of the characters aren’t shown doing anything; some are “caught” at the time of their deaths. Webber moves rather passively through a gallery of snapshots, noticing everything, doing little. He’s a writer—when fired up to action he sits down and writes something (which is seldom shared with readers). He sees, hears, feels, and sometimes empathizes, and gradually, although Webber is not a teenager and You Can’t Go Home Again is not usually classified as a young adult novel, he grows up. He does not solve a mystery, commit or prevent a murder, make or lose a fortune, have a mental breakdown, or even have sex under conditions Wolfe deems relevant to his story, although he watches other people doing these things. He just travels, meets people, and ponders the question of where a novelist from a small town in North Carolina can live.

Political correctness as we know it hadn’t been invented in 1938. Webber is not a hater, but he is politically incorrect; he talks about people the way many men of his age and type actually did. He feels sympathy for neighbors whom he knows by name as well as by the then p.c. collective term “Negroes,” then feels cheap contempt for strangers whom he classifies by the illiterate variant from of “Negroes.” His wife is Jewish, yet he professes revulsion for “the rouged lips of Jewesses.” I don’t like this, didn’t like it when Webber’s generation were talking this way, but all I can say about it in this book is that Wolfe has the dialect down. People that age who weren’t haters would casually use the vocabulary of hate speech to describe people different from themselves whom they happened not to like. 

(Some of my generation learned the habit, and, if particularly unintelligent, still have it. Talking to an employee who is unmistakably triracial, threatening a neighborhood where some of the people who belong don't even have to tell people they're Black, our Professional Bad Neighbor tried to threaten to "sell to n*s." The man's brain rot spreads daily. He wasn't born that way--another point for glyphosate. Still, the point clearly being made was that he didn't mean the illiterate-variant-form-of-"Negroes" for whom he was expressing cheap contempt to include local Black people--presumably he meant the slum dwellers that have been imported into Kingsport, wholesale, contagious diseases and all.)

In 1938 it would not have been realistic for Webber, or for Wolfe, to have been confronted with this vestige of institutionalized bigotry or asked to change it, yet Webber does have to confront hate in the way his generation did. For Webber the confrontation is more close and personal than it might have been for our grandparents; he goes to Germany and sees what increasingly extreme forms of hate look like, he feels his alienation from people who might otherwise have been his friends when he sees them conforming to the pressure to become serious haters. It’s this shock treatment, this exposure to the viciousness hate can produce, that empowers Webber to work out where his home is and reconcile himself to his own people.

Without spoiling whatever suspense the novel has, let’s just say that it has, historically, satisfied liberal readers—if they weren’t completely alienated from the book by the minor and temporary ugliness of Webber’s alienation. 

Wednesday, September 17, 2025

Book Review: War Is a Racket

Title: War Is a Racket

Author: Smedley Butler

Date: 1935

Length: 35 pages

Publisher: heritage-history.com (PDF)

Quote: "A racket is best described, I believe, as something that is not what it seems to the majority of people."

It's unfortunate that this retired Marine officer's book has been best remembered by left-wingers who, in the Cold War era, seized on the idea that the path to peace lay through falling into the hands of the Soviet Union just as Khrushchev said. What General Butler had to say about the corporate interests behind the wars of his day--and he ought to have known if anyone would, having been more decorated for more overseas military missions than anyone else alive at the time--and the poor compensation of veterans is a valuable historical document. This document has been made available in PDF form.

I recommend everyone read it. Just read it. Draw your own conclusions, from your own historical hindsight. If the computer on which you're reading this does not handle PDF well, e-mail to discuss the format and consequent cost of your printout. If your computer does handle PDF well, click here to read or download the mini-book free of charge.

Wednesday, September 10, 2025

Book Review: Busman's Honeymoon

Title: Busman’s Honeymoon

Author: Dorothy Sayers

Date: 1937

Publisher: Harper & Row

ISBN: 0-06-080823-3

Length: 370 pages

Quote: “Peter Wimsey is married—yes, actually married—to that extraordinary young woman...Peter must be forty-five if he’s a day.”

A “busman’s holiday” was a leisure trip in the bus. In this volume of their adventures Lord and Lady Peter Wimsey find themselves solving a murder mystery on their honeymoon.

Sayers had already explained the rule under which, upon marriage to Lord Peter, Harriet Vane acquired the title “Lady Peter” rather than, more logically, Lady Harriet. Possibly the off-putting sound of this title has something to do with the fact that she remains plain Harriet to herself and her friends.

Anyway, she’d helped Lord Peter solve a few other cases since he proved her innocent of the murder of her ex-boyfriend, and now they’re full partners in crime—solving them, that is. Those who’ve found Partners-for-Life will appreciate this fictional rendition of something rare and wonderful. This couple’s passion for each other is matched only by their passion for solving murder mysteries. If it makes them the most eccentric aristocrats in England, it may make them the happiest. The joy they feel at this time in their lives would probably have sustained them if their first detective adventure as a married couple had involved gruesome murders, but, perhaps out of compassion for readers, Sayers gives them a case distinguished by its cleanness.

Sayers, a Christian, never gave Lord Peter Wimsey the emotional comfort of religion. (He’s had a Christian education, has clergymen as friends, and goes around quoting Christian literature, but he lost any faith in a “personal” God in the trenches in the 1914 war.) In her mind the only really religious, as distinct from cultural, Christian element in her detective stories was that she refused to “cheapen life” by inventing unlovable stick figures who exist only to be murdered. In her novels Lord Peter’s whimsical mind, always dredging up quotes and fun facts, always guarantees a Comedy element; his empathy for the victims always guarantees a Tragedy element; and his relationship with unaccountably coy Harriet—who didn’t want to be accused of marrying him for his money, but in this volume we learn that her ex-boyfriend had also conditioned her not to like sex—added a Romance. 

We have here, therefore, a Tragedy, a Comedy, a Romance, and a Mystery, all in one volume, and the last thing Sayers would have wanted was for anyone to mistake this four-genre triumph for a Christian Novel as well. She thought of her detective stories as potboilers that subsidized the relatively smaller stack of religious writing she found time to do. Nevertheless she worked them out with all the joy of duty and pleasure that she described in The Mind of the Maker, and that she gives to Peter and Harriet—and it shows. If you like novels at all, you just about have to like Busman’s Honeymoon.

Thursday, August 14, 2025

Book Review: Death of the Party

Title: The Death of the Party

Author: Etta Faire

Date: 2019

Quote: "My dead ex-husband was in a bad mood..."

That's what some readers will hate about this well crafted mystery. It's the opening of a series but it's a full-length murder mystery in its own right...but the detective works by "channelling" ghosts who witnessed murders, or were murdered, and lives with ghosts whose stories aren't mysterious. Dead people aren't at rest and they don't go to their judgment. Depending on your religious views this may be a reason not to have the book in your house.

If you don't mind seeing the fatal dinner party through the murder victim's eyes, this is a legitimate detective story where the mystery is solved by logic and observation. And a nice, not overly detailed, period feeling (though I did spot a "scam artist" where people in the 1930s said "con artist"). And a cheerfully snarky narrator. 

Wednesday, August 21, 2024

Book Review: The Mystery of Ruby's Sugar

Title: The Mystery of Ruby's Sugar

Author: Rose Donovan

Date: 2017

Publisher: Moon Snail

Quote: "[A] certain person...said that while we're there, we might perhaps be able to carry out an assignment that would help our cause."  

That would be the cause of subverting colonial and/or capitalist enterprise. Ruby and Fina are university students who belong to a "radical," somewhat secret, left-wing group. Invited to display their dress designs to rich ladies who like their weekend work, the girls will be spying on the men in the family, perhaps stealing documents that can be used to hurt the men's business! What fun!

Rose Donovan sent out free copies of an e-book that pretends to be the whole novel but only actually contains the first three chapters. Somehow that seems in the spirit of these treacherous girls. I'm not saying I recommend this book or writer, but this plot may interest somebody Out There--that's your business. I don't judge. Well, I judge the everlovin' daylights out of books, but I don't judge readers.

Friday, October 6, 2023

Book Review: Unnatural Death

Title: Unnatural Death (U.S. edition), The Dawson Pedigree (U.K. edition)

Author: Dorothy L. Sayers

Publishers: Harper & Row *(1927), Avon (1955)

Dates: 1927 (first edition), 1955 (paperback)

Length :225 pages

Illustrations: none

Quote: “But choose somebody old and ill, in circumstances where the benefit to yourself isn’t too apparent, and use a sensible method that looks like natural death or accident...and you’re safe.”

A serious scholar and Christian thinker, Dorothy L. Sayers wanted to be remembered for her translation of Dante's Divina Commedia and for The Mind of the Makeri, or at least for her dramatic representations of events in church history. Insead, she's remembered for a series of "whimsical" murder mysteries featuring a detective called Wimsey, a young veteran who solves mysteries to fend off what we might call PTSD. The detective stories are generally recognized as some of the best written in English, but Sayers rated them mere potboilers, of no more value than the ad slogans she had written when even younger and poorer. Should we pity her> The world now remembers her primrily fr those detective stories.

What people love about her detective stories is that Sayers wrote them with concern for social issues and compassion for the individual souls her characters would have had if they'd been real. The stories were not written to a formula; they vary in length, and each has its own tone and structure. Unnatural Death may, perhaps, be taken as representative, though it's less memorable than The Nine Tailors, less perplexing than The Five Red Herrings, and less rich than Gaudy Nighti.

Unnatural Death is a period piece, full of 1930s slang and atmosphere. At the same time, it anticipates current social problems. A respetable novel of this period wouldn't use the word "lesbian," but a major character in this novel is a lesbian. Wimsey and his sidekick Bunter are Army buddies; their then-fashionable foppish mannerisms may raise some people's hopes, but they marry women., eventually  Still, this novel is less about the peculiar social position of same-sex couples--they were perfectly respectable as long as they seemed to share the consensus opinion that no sane person could be physically attracted to a person of the same sex--is a minor concern in this novel. There's a look at race relations, too, and at the English feudal-hierarchical system. Sayers never missed.a chance to mention that, despite his education in a Christian school system, Wimsey is not really a Christian; he could benefit rom the consolation of religious faith, but he never has any faith. The primary focus of its attention is why even burdensome geriatric patients who will never be missed should not be euthanized, no matter how much their heirs may need the money.

Then there's the other distinguishing feature of Sayers' detective stories: the mystery can be solved if you happen to remember the right item of general knowledge. Your feelings about the characters won't help you solve the mystery along with Wimsey. Scientific facts will. Likable people can be guilty; repulsive people, even if guilty of other things, can be innocent of the murder. Sayers was a Christian, and some characters in each of her novels are also Christians, but the novels are not Sunday School books; everyone, including irreligious Wimsey, can quote Christian poems and songs but nobody ever gets into a full-length exposition of the gospel, and people's religious faith does not help identify whether charcters are nnocent, guilty, or going to be the Next Victim.

My copies of Sayers' detective stories are all older than I am, but the Wimsey stories have been reprinted every few years. They're worth it.

Friday, February 17, 2023

Book Review: Good Things That Were

Title: The Good Things That Were Once Under the Sycamore Are Now No More

Author: George Gibson

Publisher: George Gibson

Date: 1980

ISBN: none

Length: 16 pages

Quote: “St. Charles, a place where I’ve labored and worked all my life…turned into what some would call a Ghost Town.”

George Gibson, born in 1905, reminisces about his life as a coal miner, preacher, and union organizer in Virginia. Labor union activity was less dangerous in Virginia than it was in Kentucky; Gibson describes injuries from hard work in the mines, not from cave-ins, explosions, or those infamous outbursts of violence. He could probably have said more if he hadn’t wanted to fit his story, plus photos and other people’s statements of support for what he was saying, onto eight sheets of printer paper.

About such a short book, it’s hard to say much, but I have shared this book with older people from Lee County. (Very few people come from St. Charles, though the settlement by that name still exists.) They recognized the names of people mentioned and agreed that Gibson described those people and their activities accurately. This flimsy booklet is thus a primary document of local history. Buy it when you can.


 

Friday, December 30, 2022

Book Review: Bud Not Buddy

Title: Bud Not Buddy

Author: Christopher Paul Curtis

Publisher: Random House

Date: 1999

ISBN: 0-440-41328-1

Length: 243 pages

Quote: “Especially don’t you ever let anyone call you Buddy…Buddy is a dog’s name or a name that someone’s going to use on you if they’re being false-friendly. Your name is Bud, period.”

Sound advice, North or South: Unless “Buddy” or “Son” or “Honey” or “Baby” or “Sweetie” really is a private pet name you use, with conscious irony, in private moments alone with one very special person, and you’d want to think twice about it even then—when you hear those words plopping out of something that is looking at you, you keep your eyes on it and feel for your weapon. People of good will do not call people names like that.

People of ill will do, however, use the claim that they do as a test. If you fall for it, you’re stupid and deserve whatever else you get from them, which is guaranteed not to be good.

Curtis’ character, Bud, never knew his father, and didn’t know his streetwise-too-late mother for very long. It’s 1936; there’ve been deaths in every extended family and in most immediate families. Bud is one of a multitude of orphan children but he holds on to what’s left of his mother—her words, and five advertising flyers for a band called the Dusky Devastators of the Depression. (This was, Curtis explains in an afterword, the name of a real band, with which his own grandfather played.) Bud’s mother didn’t keep a lot of souvenirs of anything so Bud has a feeling that the leader of this band might be his father.

As most of the millennial generation probably know, given the huge success of this book, Bud will never find his father. But he will find a band of extraordinarily nice people who accept him as a member of the band and…oh, read the book. This is, after all, a Depression Story. Christopher Paul Curtis was not alive in the 1930s but his parents were, and he wrote the kind of Depression Story that people who remembered the 1930s told. The stock market’s crash did not directly affect most Americans but its economic ramifications dragged on long enough that they did. Infectious diseases like polio and tuberculosis became epidemics; rich people died too, but more poor people died. A lot of people remember long, hard times—as when my father came down with polio, didn’t die and forced his arms and legs to get back to work, but he basically stopped growing for much of the 1930s. But what kind of story was that? The stories people told about the Depression were about the good times, the heartwarming things that made the financial worries, bereavements, even actual hunger in some cases, seem like backgrounds that only made the good stories sound better. To hear them talk, in the 1930s everybody was poor (not true) but everybody except a few ridiculous jerks was very, very nice (probably not true either, but be fair—did your elders actually say that or was that just the way all Depression Stories ran together in your mind and sounded to you?).

The music they listened to was similar to the stories they told. Some songs from the 1930s express grief and sorrow. More of them express cheerfulness, even manic, pumped-up, forced cheerfulness. If the happy days were not yet “here again,” they soon would be. There would be metaphoric bluebirds of happiness over the White Cliffs of Dover, though any birds literally flying there were more likely to be any of dozens of other species than Sialia sialis. So pack up your troubles in your old kit bag and smile, smile, smile! (This was when the United States became the world’s toothiest nation. Tooth-baring does not, in fact, prove that anyone is still alive, but people talked as if it did.) At this period the efforts being made to help people who became “depressed” or alcoholic were pretty horrible, so, if you wanted to survive, you tried to seem cheerful. One thing people did for extra money was compete in ballroom dancing endurance contests. Since a lot of people were competing for these prizes, some couples kept grimly shuffling around the ballroom, taking turns sleeping on each other’s shoulders, for several days. See! They were DANCING! FUN FUN FUN!!!

So the good stories that people wanted to tell, and hear, were the ones that were actually unusual, with the surprise happy endings. My grandmother was pronounced dead, obituaries were printed, burial arranged. (That was commonplace.) Then she came out of her coma long enough to wink at a young doctor, scaring him badly enough that he wanted to try insulin shock to make sure she was well and truly dead before she was buried. So he was granted permission to inject an insulin overdose and, instead of dying, Grandmother sat up, got well, and lived for another thirty-nine years. (That was interesting, a real Depression Story.)

The President had had polio, just like some young relative you weren't allowed to visit, but everyone saw him, in the newsreels, walking and talking as if he’d never been ill in his life. And bad men roamed around robbing banks and shooting people, but good men came out to kill them or put them in prison. And extremely bad men were doing horrible things to your relatives back in the Old Country, but there was a plan for taking care of them, too, if everyone cooperated and planted Victory Gardens and stayed within their rations. So, smile the while you kissed the soldiers in your family sad adieu, and direct your feet to the sunny side of the street—and strike up that band! “Big” bands, often actually small groups that made “big” noises with wind instruments that could never be completely on key, were the fashion. Saxophones blared out polkas and marches and thoroughly cheerful songs about “the blues.” Funerals called for really jubilant songs about “When the Saints Go Marching In.”

Bud is still an orphan but he has grandparents. And friends. And a choice of future careers, which may include playing a saxophone in a band. That’s only a fictional imitation of a Depression Story, but it meets the criteria for a real one. Maybe in some family, somewhere, it was true.

Wednesday, December 28, 2022

Can an Individual Create a Bill of Rights?

Sometimes we laugh about committees; we joke that if the horse had been designed by a committee, it’d look like the camel. We tend to think the horse is soooo much nicer to look at or live with.

People who lived in places where the camel was the native species did not share this feeling. The law of ancient Israel actually contained a rule that the king was not to keep horses. The idea was that donkeys were for riding around the farm, oxen were for heavy work, camels were for crossing the desert, and horses were just for show! Ancient Israelites had seen foreign warlords ride their horses into battle, where the idea was to kill someone else’s horse and then try to get your own horse to trample him before somebody killed your horse, and they saw how cruel and wasteful this was and they wanted no part of it. They had no such problems with the camel. Hebrew and Arabic words come in families, and the word for "camel" is part of the same family with words for “perfect” and “beautiful” and “just right for its intended purpose.” The camel was not meant to be a horse. It’s just right for its intended purpose.

Similarly, our Bill of Rights, which was the product of a lot of intensive bickering by a committee, is just right for its intended purpose. No single person could have got all those ten important points in there, right at the beginning. Nobody’s ever just written a Bill of Rights all by perself.

Franklin Delano Roosevelt, however, was not exactly a normal man. His going down with polio as an adult, and then recovering as an adult, was like a metaphor for his character.

Without vaccinations or even earlier exposure, most adults just build up enough resistance that they don’t go down with polio like that. Adults can be immune carriers of polio but they rarely show recognizable symptoms of the disease. So FDR lacked something that most people have.

Then again, most people who have polio at any age are disabled by it for a long time. They have to work to be able to walk again. Adults who notice that they have polio usually die. FDR forced himself through the exercises and stood up and walked and worked for more than fifteen years. So he also had something that most people lack.

Among the other things he had was an oversized ego, so oversized that he thought he could just sit down and write a new Bill of Rights. He seriously thought that, and talked about it in public. Among the things he lacked was any idea how impossible it was that his ideas could lead to what his “new bill of rights” claimed he wanted.

The right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms or mines of the nation;

The right to earn enough to provide adequate food and clothing and recreation;

The right of every farmer to raise and sell his products at a return which will give him and his family a decent living;

The right of every businessman, large and small, to trade in an atmosphere of freedom from unfair competition and domination by monopolies at home or abroad;

The right of every family to a decent home;

The right to adequate medical care and the opportunity to achieve and enjoy good health;

The right to adequate protection from the economic fears of old age, sickness, accident, and unemployment;

The right to a good education.

FDR also had four presidential terms. He was going into his last one when he read his “new bill of rights” on the radio in 1944. He wanted everybody to have, first and foremost, a useful and remunerative job.

That is one of the things a person needs to have in order to be a good citizen. We’ve tried just throwing money at people, instead. It’s like saying, “Nobody needs anything you can do, you’re useless, we hate you, but let it never be said that we didn’t give you the stuff you needed to survive. Not actual grocery money, you’d probably spend that the wrong way, you worthless useless bum, but we’ll give you some food. Well, yes, it is pretty nasty, but beggars can’t be choosers and since you didn’t earn the money to buy food you’d like, why should you expect better quality food than your dog? If anything we prefer the dog to you. Now, now, now, you don’t need soap to survive. You don’t need toilet paper to survive. We don’t actually want you having cash you might use to buy those things. But we can certainly give you plenty of food, even if half of it is rotten and the other half is zucchini. Well, if you had a freezer you could freeze the zucchini, anyway. You’re not expecting us to give you a freezer are you? Of all the nerve! Here we’ve been kind enough to GIVE you forty zucchini and you expect anybody to GIVE you a freezer as well!” 

We are an overprivileged nation. You have to be horribly overprivileged to imagine that someone who does not own a freezer is going to think kind thoughts about anyone who dumps forty zucchini on their doorstep.

No. We cannot just feed adult human beings, and we need to stop trying. We need to integrate them into the community. They must have jobs. They must be able to earn the money to pay for what they choose to eat. If they’re going to be good citizens of a democratic nation they should be earning at least ten times as much as they spend on food. You don’t ever want anyone to feel that all their day’s work has earned is food. Work all day, choke down a little food, repeat—that’s not life in a democratic nation. If the body’s needs are going to be satisfied by a dinner that costs five or ten dollars, then the job needs to pay fifty or a hundred dollars a day, in order to count.

If the dinner costs only ten cents, then the person might feel satisfied by a job that pays a dollar a day. When FDR was born, a dollar was still an acceptable day’s wages because a dime would still buy an acceptable day’s food rations. Almost every American in FDR’s generation was able to earn that dollar a day. Once FDR’s policies got rolling for my generation, we see where we’ve got to. A lot of people who want to earn fifty or a hundred dollars a day are being denied that opportunity and being offered food handouts instead.

Data point: The longest this underpaid writer has just stopped buying food, because spending every dang penny on food is such a miserable substitute for a living, is seven weeks. So far. It would have made more of a statement if I'd starved, but I had a stockpile of caffeinated drinks and a not-a-lawn full of edible "weeds," and I felt perky while losing only flab.

We as a nation need to criminalize telling anyone “Well, we have food banks, we have food stamps.” Able-bodied people do not need food. They need JOBS. We have to break this fixation on feeding people. We don’t even know what they can digest, for pity’s sake. We need to replace “Oh, there’s a poor person! I’ll give person some food!” with “Please, Mr. or Ms. Poor Person, I need your help with this JOB that will pay more than the cost of another day’s food.” Just keep biting your lips together, a little bleeding won’t kill you, until you have that hundred dollars to offer the person for a JOB.

FDR also thought everyone had a right to raise and sell products. Get that—he didn’t do too well with policies that protected the right to raise and sell your own food, but at least he did recognize that it was a fundamental human right. One reason why this right is crucial is that, when people’s right to raise and sell food is not being interfered with, people who are “trying to help” can’t distract themselves from what is really needed, which is the JOB, with their crazy babbling about food.

Imagine a world where we still took that one seriously. “Let’s use tax dollars to build a lot of slums where nothing green can grow, tell poor people they have to live in the said slums, and give them a lot of food!” would be a proposition nobody could seriously make. “What is the matter with you? Poor people already have their kitchen gardens. Get back in here. Lie down. You need rest—and treatment.”

FDR actually thought that people, even poor people, had the right to achieve and enjoy good health. FDR happened to know a little about how good health is achieved. Not only he and his wife, but his macho celebrity relative, Theodore Roosevelt, had fought their way from a sickly sedentary life to an active and vigorous life. Before he started swaggering around the world "carrying a big stick," TR had been a mopey little nerdboy with asthma. That's how FDR knew that vigorous outdoor exercise was his ticket back to life after polio.

A few readers Out There, Grandma Bonnie Peters' contemporaries, may still remember the FDR era. This web site would love to hear from youall. What do you remember best about the early 1940s? Was it...the "Victory Gardens"? Toward the goal of financing the War, the Roosevelts urged everyone to raise as much of their own food as they could. The idea was that more good healthy American potatoes could be shipped out to feed the troops, but the Roosevelts knew that gardening would also build healthier young Americans. They even promoted efforts to get children from urban areas placed as summer boarders in rural homes, so poor little city children could get some healthy fresh air and outdoor exercise.

In his time FDR's writing his own Bill of Rights was controversial. Some thought that being in the White House too long had given him delusions of monarchy. In the 1940s most Americans thought that a man who had no farm to work on had better get himself into town and find a job, and if he didn't get a job, why, something was badly wrong with him and he probably belonged in jail. Why would any reasonable President bother his head about that, they wondered. Since when was it the federal government's business to find jobs for people? All the federal government had to do was fend off invading armies, coin money, and deliver the mail, and people would take care of everything else for themselves. People were proud of responsibility rather than afraid of it.

No matter how much the "Progressives" carried on about the situations where responsible individuals didn't make everything perfect, by some indicators people were better off then than now. Yes, people (even at this web site) can be heard to say that "progress has been made"...but they don't mean "People pay more taxes now," or "Federal regulations are more complicated now." They mean "Antibiotics and even antiviral treatments have been discovered," or "People have at least been educated to resist certain specific forms of prejudice, although even intelligent people fall into the Genetic Fallacy of Thinking," or "Rapid travel and communication are fun."

We could do better than insist that today's "Progressives" focus on working back toward FDR's original attempt to rewrite the Bill of Rights, ludicrous piece of presumption that it was. One person can't write a Bill of Rights but FDR did know more about what can actually help disadvantaged people, e.g. people with major disabilities, than today's Progs seem to know.

Tuesday, September 27, 2022

Book Review: Blood of the North

Title: Blood of the North

Author: James B. Hendryx

Date: 1938

Publisher: Triangle/Doubleday

ISBN: none

Length: 278 pages

Quote: "Time'll come when Angus'll be wantin' a wife, mayhap." "Aye, an' Jean could go further an' fare worse."

James B. Hendryx wrote several of these cheap young-adult novels, apparently attempting to appeal to boys and girls at the same time. Blood of the North is a "Western" adventure story, although it's set in the Northwest rather than the Southwest, with fur traders instead of cowboys. It's also a romance. Young Angus Murchie, whose late lamented mother was "Indian," doesn't think he has a right to marry bonnie blue-eyed Jean McPherson--even though their elders think they'd make a perfect pair. Angus has to prove himself a storybook hero, brave, tough, woods-wise, and also able to out-trick a despicable developer in real estate law, before Jean can sweetly tell him that "the really great chiefs who were your mother's ancestors" will be a lot to live up to. Fade out with a kiss, as all romances of this period always do. To find out how Angus proves himself you have to read the book.

Novels like this one, forerunners of movies and TV shows, used to be regarded as a sort of vice--mentioned in some church rules right alongside dancing and gambling--and students used to be warned not to waste their eyesight reading them. It is therefore ironically appropriate that surviving copies are worth more now than they were when new.

Fair disclosure: I did not particularly care for the story. So what? I seldom do like novels. If "Rocky Mountain High" is your favorite song and Lake Louise is your favorite landscape, you probably would like this book for the landscapes alone. If you're interested in the history of the 1930s and 1940s, here is an authentic artifact of pop culture from that period. Or you might want it just because it's old enough by now to count as a decorative item.


 

Sunday, February 20, 2022

Book Review: The Hills Are Calling

This Sunday Book review is being pre-posted, so there's no adorable adoptable animal...how would I know which animals are still unadopted at the time of reading? 

Book Review: The Hills Are Calling

Author: Irene B. Brand

Date: 1990

Publisher: Mountain State Press

ISBN: 0-941092-224

Length: 189 pages

Quote: “‘Don’t cross my path again. I only warn once.’ As Adams climbed unsteadily into the saddle, he held Don with his wicked stare, and Don thought, Why is this man wretched?”

Irene B. Brand’s intention in this “inspirational novel” was to present a good oldfashioned romance that avoids the ordinary kind of unhealthy fantasies, so it is my sad duty to warn readers that this whole novel is one long indulgence in an unhealthy fantasy. Here is no premarital sex, no murders or elopements or impossible fortunes. The romance is clean, with just a few family-filtered kisses before the protagonists are married. The book is still pervaded by one of the most harmful fantasies in which Christians can indulge.

That fantasy is: “Christians, or at least Christian ministers, know all the answers in life.” Don, the minister given the leading part in The Hills Are Calling, comes to town and immediately falls in love with one man (Adams, the mean drunk) and one woman (Addie). It is probably not homoeroticism, but a desire to make this novel a bit different from every other wholesome-type romance you’ve ever read, that prompts Brand to tell us that Don is impressed by Adams’ handsome face, but not “even the eyes of love” could call Addie beautiful. However, what Don is really in love with is not these people as they are, but his fantasy that he can rescue them from their “wretchedness.” Don is not physically afraid of Adams merely because the bigger, stronger man threatens to beat him up, and later does; he just holds on to his perception that nobody becomes a mean drunk unless he is really “wretched” and in need of the sort of counselling Don can offer. When he meets the two single women in town, the pretty one who works at the post office and the plain one who is complaining about a local character tampering with her mail, he’s not (conscious of being) attracted to the plain one because he senses that he’s not enough of a catch for the pretty one; he’s drawn to the plain one because, although he never thinks about a woman’s right to privacy needing any defense, he wants to cure her “bitterness” with more counselling.

In a really inspirational story, even on the level of Christy, events would shake Don out of his pseudospiritual pigheadedness. Some people who did or did not go to his church would know things Don didn’t know. If not physically crippled, he’d be at least mentally humiliated, forced to confront his imperfection and mortality. Although Don’s self-confidence is a realistic portrait of the act very young men tend to put on, he needs to develop a more realistic form of self-esteem, a faith that the Great Spirit can still work through even complacent oafs like him if he consents to move his ego out of the way.

In The Hills Are Calling, what needs to happen, to make Don a believable or likable character, fails to happen. He steamrollers along, his fantasy undisturbed by reality. Adams is wretched! And Addie is bitter! And both of them are so eager, and so grateful, for Don’s counselling! (Well, at least after Don improbably beats him up Adams is grateful for Don’s counselling.) This by itself would not be altogether unbelievable—once in a while a very young Christian does get to watch an alcoholic hit bottom, and Addie wouldn’t be the first lonely girl who, in the bad old days when a woman really couldn’t depend on her ability to work for her living, expressed a need for counselling in order to snag a promising preacher. But nobody else knows anything Don needs to learn, either! All the old married people in the fictional town are just sheep, bleating gratefully about how much they need a minister...and although, in real life, this by itself would be an indicator of how much Don stands to learn from them, the story doesn’t go on long enough for Don to see the indicator. At the end of the book other characters’ lives have changed, but Don is still the selfrighteous adolescent fool he was at the beginning of the story, with no hope for change and people depending on him for guidance, and God help them all.

The book doesn’t fail all its characters, or readers, as badly as it fails Don. What deserves mentioning is the fact that, apart from their “less educated” dialect, the townsfolk aren’t portrayed as hillbilly stereotypes. Adams is, of course, a stereotypical drunkard (apparently not a true alcoholic), and Addie is a stereotypical 1930s romance heroine as played by Greta Garbo. The other townsfolk get only cameo appearances, as generic parishioners—but not as hillbillies. The ones Don doesn’t have to pray over in their sickbeds, or bury, actually work. They’re either much older than Don, or much younger, but they’re presented as the kind of people we can believe Don would be interested in knowing.

The blurb promises “humor, drama, pathos, and superb dialogue.” ??? It’s a romance, people. There is a minor character who tries to make people laugh, and in real life his twinkly eyes might have that effect, but the novel is no more hilarious than it is suspenseful. I didn’t laugh, or even smile, once while reading The Hills Are Calling. The drama is about as predictable as it is in most romance novels: Jack shall have Jill and all will be well. The pathos is believable: this is the 1930s but Brand actually lived in West Virginia and didn't confuse it with the fantasy of "AppaLAYsha" from Eleanor Roosevelt's guilt trips. The dialogue is readable, but “superb” is not an adjective that comes to my mind. 

The book would be more satisfactory if it didn’t have to compete with its blurb. I wish Don had learned a lesson; my fingers itch to add a few chapters to the end—“Then Don remembered the little boy who’d told him he fought like Max Schmeling when he’d finally pitched into Ezra Adams on Paul’s behalf...and Don realized that this big, mean drunk was fighting like Joe Louis.” Or, “‘Reading my letters again, are you?’ Addie yelled, as the still-warm clothing he had just dropped on the floor draped around Don’s head. ‘What’s the matter with you now?’ he asked, wondering what had become of her joyous new life in Jesus. ‘The matter with me is that I’m married to you,’ Addie bayed, ‘but I won’t be for long!’” Still, I could deal with the limitations the romance genre imposes if the blurb hadn’t promised “humor, drama, pathos, and superb dialogue.” Authors need to stop writing inflated blurbs for each other, or letting others write inflated blurbs for them. This is a sweet, clean romance, if you’re in the mood for one; it is not The Grapes of Wrath, Gone with the Wind, or even Christy. 

Monday, January 15, 2018

Book Review: A Pearl in Every Oyster

Title: A Pearl in Every Oyster


Author: Frank Sullivan

Date: 1962

Publisher: Little Brown & Company

ISBN: none

Length: 290 pages

Quote: "I settle hash and coin phrases. I beggar description."

These were, of course, only a few tasks in the job description of Frank Sullivan's best-known character, Mr. Arbuthnot the Cliche Expert. Mr. Arbuthnot was a very busy man. The editors put him on the stand ten times in this collection of 35 articles.

Sullivan wrote mostly clean comedy, despite the smutty (and false) suggestion in one piece that a sailor who picks up hookers might be healthier than his high-minded buddies who visit art museums instead. All other articles in this collection are completely G-rated. Cliches were Sullivan's favorite theme, and receive enough attention to satisfy me in the articles that do not feature Mr. Arbuthnot. Other topics joked about in this book include recliner chairs, food vending machines, Sullivan's dislike of venison, and so on.

If you can imagine such a thing as sober, dignified comedy, that's what this book consists of. Well, it was written for men, by a man, in a period when men understood the term "men" as opposite to "boys" and "bums" as well as opposite to "women." You don't have to be a property owner, voter, and taxpayer to enjoy this book, but it helps.

You don't have to remember the 1930s, either, although some of the articles are really historical period pieces. Actually, you don't have to remember any period to enjoy an old book; you have to make notes of what you don't understand, look up topics (or ask people who remember, if any of them are still around), and come back and enjoy the book with understanding. However, it takes more research for me to enjoy Will Rogers' articles, although I do, and it would probably take more research for a younger reader to enjoy Art Buchwald's, than it takes for me to appreciate this book.

That's both good and bad. After doing enough research to appreciate a collection of Will Rogers, you'd have material for a term paper. After doing enough research to appreciate A Pearl in Every Oyster, you'll merely get a few extra chuckles out of reading it.

There is no outline or chronological sequence in this book. Each article was written separately and can be read separately.

The construction of this book left something to be desired. From the outside it resembles one of those Dover paperbacks that lie flat when read and stay bound for years. It's not. My copy already has a cracked spine.

Recommended, nevertheless, to all Sullivan fans, history buffs, nostalgia trippers, and comedy collectors, A Pearl in Every Oyster has reached the collector price range. This web site can offer it for $10 per book + $5 per package + $1 per online payment. Three more books of this size will fit into that $5 package, and most books cost $5, so please browse on. 

Thursday, January 4, 2018

Book Review: Nods and Becks

Title: Nods and Becks



Author: Franklin P. Adams

Date: 1944

Publisher: McGraw-Hill

ISBN: none

Length: 242 pages

Quote: “What worried us the first day of school was how everybody but us in the room appeared to know the words and music of these songs. Was the world, we thought, frightened to dizziness, like that? Was everybody to know more than we? And that, Dr. Freud, is a fear we never have been able to overwhelm.”

Thus Adams accounts for his long career as a news writer and trivia expert, star of a radio quiz show called “Information Please.” 

Although this book contains some fun facts, it’s not as rich a source of trivia as might be hoped. It’s a souvenir collection, containing several tidbits of fact, opinion, and whimsy from F.P.A.’s humor column “The Conning Tower.” ("F.P.A." was his newspaper byline, and when he printed books with his full name on them his readership were motivated to buy them by seeing the initials in parentheses beside the name.) It includes a whimsical (yes, whimsical) obituary for a fellow humorist, reminding readers that Adams’ generation were of necessity more comfortable with the thought of human mortality than ours is.

It’s also a period piece, containing a comic speech called “Women Can’t Play Poker” (specifying “in my club”) that addressed women in an adult audience as “girls,” and dialect jokes that poke fun at dialect jokes by deliberately mixing up the dialects parodied, and sympathetic comments on smoking, and other offenses against modern taste. The position of this web site is that we need to preserve more of the books that contained these things. As Adams says on page 64, “Students and professors of journalism should study the differences between the ethics, or at any rate the common practices, of forty years ago and those of today.”

So here is Adams, growing old gracefully in the 1920s, 1930s, and early 1940s. He was loved by many of his contemporaries, and several printings of his book were made. I think it looks best in the format “in compliance with the government’s regulations for conserving paper.”

That format allows him to skip from subject to subject with just a row of asterisks between the pieces, which appear in no order and skip back and forth among twenty-five years of columns, newspaper and magazine “fillers,” speeches, and full-length articles. On pages 14-15 are printed a reminiscence abut “Information Please,” a quatrain about boredom, a sonnet about talkative children, a short rant about clichés, and an aphorism defining an optimist and a pessimist. On pages 52-53 we get a definition of middle age, a couplet about taxes, the beginning of a song parody about a tax on maple syrup, a reflection on interest in one’s work, a gloomy rhyme called “Valentine,” a wisecrack about anti-intellectualism, a search for the origin of the phrase “New Deal,” and a search for the origin of the phrase “Say it ain’t true, Joe.” Pages 190-191 contain reflections on writers’ pay, signs of winter, newspapers that have ceased to exist, a retort to a phrase in one of President Hoover’s speeches, puns on the names of colleges, and thoughts on job hopping. I suspect Adams would have enjoyed compiling Link Logs.

The more you’ve read of other books from this historical era, the more you’ll chortle. Some of Adams’ jokes are just plain funny; some are funny if you catch their references. Like Will Rogers’ comedy, Adams’ may be best shared with a grandparent, but sometimes readers would have to smile if they didn’t recognize a single celebrity name.

Well, I enjoy this book...but I was greatly blessed. Early in life I discovered F.P.A.’s short pieces in older relatives’ old books, and instead of being told, “Ooohhh, don’t read that, it was before your time, here, quick, read something you already know all about,” I could ask, “Who was Secretary Ickes?” and be told all that my relatives remembered, and share the joke with them. So I was able to laugh at lots of things that were, technically, before my time, from “Pogo” back through F.P.A. and several of the friends and colleagues mentioned in this book. This blessing expanded: I learned to look things up, and became able to laugh at Mark Twain and Artemus Ward.

If you, too, appreciate a lighthearted look at the news items of a bygone time, you’ll enjoy Nods and Becks. It’s clean, subtle, generally polite humor. Adams didn’t preach to his contemporaries, “You don’t need outdated stereotypes of other demographic groups to make a story funny,” and he probably couldn’t even have imagined the need to preach to today’s so-called comedians, “You don’t need vulgar words and gross-out content to make a story funny.” When you have real comedic talent (like Dave Barry, or like either Scott or Douglas Adams) you can just be funny without those things.

F.P.A. is probably best remembered for a rather glib reworking of a traditional rhyme, “‘Tobacco is a filthy weed.’ (I like it.) ‘It satisfies no natural need.’ (I like it.)...”, which is not reprinted in Nods and Becks. Perhaps he and his editor thought he deserved to be remembered by a comment on Socialist Realism:

“Let us then be down-and-outers,
Knowing we can’t fight our fate;
All defeatists and misdoubters,
Learn to belabor and to hate.”

Or perhaps by the things he learned by writing for newspapers: “That many newspaper men ought not to be in the business...That the best and the best-paid reporters don’t get paid half of what I think they deserve...That anthracite is a noun, and only a noun.”

Although this review will appear online in the morning, I am writing it late in the evening, and while that little black-and-white movie of How a Young Reporter (as Might Be Played by Charlie Chaplin) Learned That Anthracite Is Only Ever a Noun is playing in my mind, I think I’ll turn in. Comedy is a delightful way to relax before bed.

Nods and Becks was popular in its day and has not reached collectors' prices as outrageous as might have been expected; lots of copies are still floating around. Send $5 per book, $5 per package, and $1 per online payment, to order this book as part of a package to which you can add three more books of similar size, including some by living authors whom we can encourage by sending percentages of the payment.