Thursday, April 5, 2018

Book Review: Emil and the Detectives

Title: Emil and the Detectives


Author: Erich Kästner

Translator: May Massee

Date: 1929 (Doubleday), 1965 (Scholastic)

Publisher: Doubleday, Scholastic

ISBN: none

Length: 160 pages

Illustrations: drawings by Walter Trier

Quote: “The train this coach belongs to travels to Berlin. And probably in this compartment, in the next chapter, strange things will happen.”

Well, yes, actually in real life it is unusual to have your money stolen on a train, though television might have given us the impression that it’s commonplace. Anyway, this is the story of how a very nice little boy, travelling alone for the first time, not only gets robbed but recovers his money and proves the thief guilty. He has some help, of course, from grown-up police detectives, and from other children—a gang of allegedly 100 boys who’ve organized themselves to help visitors rather than bully them, and his girl cousin, who is called Pony though “her real name is something quite different.”

With its period-perfect drawings and politically correct plot elements (children work together! city people are nice! the girl is as tough as any of the boys!), Emil and the Detectives was all set to win prizes even in translation, so the good news for kids must have been that it was as “exciting” and as funny as adults claimed. Kästner addressed the very young but, if you’re an adult reading it for the first time, you don’t absolutely have to find a child to whom to read it aloud. It’s only more fun that way.

I think I’d read this book, and dismissed it as merely a boys’ story, when I was seven or eight, but I thoroughly enjoyed it when I was about forty and The Nephews were between the ages of three and ten. Even the members of that group who is/are, in real life, actually niece/s enjoyed it as a family read-along.


To buy it here, send $5 per book, $5 per package, and $1 per online payment to the appropriate address at the very bottom of the screen (or use the Paypal button when I make the time to put it here). Emil and the Three Twins would fit into the package and you might even have room for Lisa and Lottie. 

No comments:

Post a Comment